Ellen Langer

Gaining Control ·

|

Listen to Counterclockwise

In the New York Times of Sunday, June 20, there’s a story about how one hospital botched 65 of 92 prostate cancer treatments. There’s a strange upside to stories like these. People who read or hear about them are likely to become less trusting of the medical world when it comes to their own health. I’m not suggesting that in general doctors, nurses and their staff are in any way incompetent or ill intended. It’s just that we know more about our health—or at least should know—then anyone else and so it makes no sense to turn over complete control to anyone else.

As I wrote in Counterclockwise, I remember being stunned when my mother found out she had breast cancer and asked me if she were going to die. Asking questions like these of others highlights our mindless acceptance of expertise. Experts no matter how smart and well meaning can only know so much. We need to take back control of our health. I describe several ways to do this but this is only a tease so I want go into any particulars now. The first step, however, is to admit that we are not helpless over our diseases.

Comment

Thank you for producing another book; I always find your writing a joy to read and your research fascinating.

It seems to be a fact of modern life that in all areas, from health care to airplane tickets, the better educated consumer gets much better results. My wife’s breast cancer certainly turned me into someone who wants to work with a doctor, rather than being treated by one (to the extreme of eventually publishing two medical papers based on studying my wife’s case).

But I also know people who, upon facing cancer, want to know absolutely nothing about it. They want to view their doctor (however randomly and without comparison they came to have that particular doctor) as expert so (I believe) they can compartmentalize the disease and give it as little sway over their lives as possible.

Their way is not mine, but I cannot assume that it is not what is best for them. I content myself with the thought that everyone must find their own path through a disease like cancer (although, I sure wish more hospitals would make an attempt to screen for a basic handicap like serious depression before embarking on a difficult cancer treatment regimen). The psychological issues for both doctor and patient in the treatment of cancer could easily fill a book with never a dull moment, IMHO.

Ron Burk · Jun 25, 12:04 AM

Commenting is closed for this article.